Baldur’s Gate 3 reset expectations for story-driven RPGs. Ash & Oath is a much smaller thing: a browser action RPG from one person, made partly to find out what AI can and can’t do in game development.
Actual gameplay from Ash & Oath · The Cinder watchpost.
An honest comparison
Baldur’s Gate 3 isn’t the competition.
Larian Studios released Baldur’s Gate 3 in August 2023 after an Early Access period that began in 2020. Built on Dungeons & Dragons rules, it won Game of the Year at The Game Awards 2023 and has reportedly sold more than 20 million copies.
Its studio grew to more than 400 people during development. Performances, branching dialogue and reactive scenes at that level take enormous human effort. That’s one of the clearest examples of what a solo AI-assisted project can’t reproduce.
An honest comparison
Side by side.
Baldur’s Gate 3 and Ash & Oath at a glance
Detail
Baldur’s Gate 3
Ash & Oath
Made by
Larian Studios, a team of more than 400
One person, working with AI tools
Combat
Turn-based, using D&D rules
Real-time action with dodging and guarding
Players
Single-player or co-op
Single-player
Price
Paid game
All five released chapters are free
An honest comparison
Where they overlap, and where they don’t.
What feels familiar
Honestly, not much beyond the RPG label. Both let you pick a class and grow it over a long journey, and both have a camp you return to between outings. In Ash & Oath the camp is mainly about upgrades, with some conversations, and a companion joins your journey partway through.
What’s different
Baldur’s Gate 3 is about choice, consequence and companions with whole storylines of their own. Ash & Oath tells a much more linear story through its chapters, and its main focus is real-time combat and gear.
An honest comparison
Which should you play?
Play Baldur’s Gate 3 for one of the richest stories in RPGs. Try Ash & Oath if you want quick real-time combat in a browser and an unusual, openly experimental way of making a game.
No. Combat is in real time, with dodging, guarding and parrying.
Does it have branching stories like Baldur’s Gate 3?
Not at anything like that scale. The main story follows a clear route through its chapters.
Is it a D&D game?
No. Ash & Oath has its own original world and rules.
Five free chapters
One person’s dark fantasy, playable in your browser.
An honest comparison
One person. A lot of AI. No pretending otherwise.
Ash & Oath is a passion project from a single developer, and part of its purpose is to test what AI can do in game development. AI tools helped create its art, 3D models, audio and code, and it’s still in beta.
Baldur’s Gate 3 and all related names are trademarks of their respective owners. Ash & Oath is an independent project, with no connection to or endorsement from them. Details about Baldur’s Gate 3 were checked in October 2026 and may have changed.