The Witcher 3 set a standard for open-world storytelling that big studios still chase. Ash & Oath comes from the other end of the scale: one person, experimenting with AI, on a passion project.
Actual gameplay from Ash & Oath · The Cinder watchpost.
An honest comparison
The Witcher 3 isn’t the competition.
CD Projekt Red released The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt in May 2015, and followed it with the Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine expansions. The company reported spending about 306 million złoty, roughly $81 million, on development and marketing, and sales have passed 60 million copies.
Reports put the number of people involved at around 1,500 once outside contributors are counted. Numbers like those give a useful sense of what a one-person project is not.
An honest comparison
Side by side.
The Witcher 3 and Ash & Oath at a glance
Detail
The Witcher 3
Ash & Oath
Made by
CD Projekt Red, with about 1,500 people reportedly involved
One person, working with AI tools
Budget
About $81 million, including marketing
A solo passion project
World
A vast open world built on an established fantasy series
Original chapter-based maps and an original story
Price
Paid game with paid expansions
All five released chapters are free
An honest comparison
Where they overlap, and where they don’t.
What feels familiar
Both games are dark fantasy with monsters, and both let you learn about a foe before you fight it. Ash & Oath’s bestiary explains enemy cues and boss phases, and its world guide covers the fallen kingdoms. The resemblance is mostly one of atmosphere.
What’s different
The Witcher 3’s strength is its writing, its quest design and a fully voiced cast. Ash & Oath is an action RPG first, and its quests are simple by comparison. You also choose and shape your own hero, instead of playing an established character.
An honest comparison
Which should you play?
Play The Witcher 3 for a huge, beautifully written adventure. Try Ash & Oath if you’d like a short free visit to a much smaller world, and you’re interested in how it was built.
Not in the way The Witcher 3 is. It’s made of separate chapter maps that you explore, with optional dungeons.
Can I pick my own hero?
Yes. You choose one of four classes and a body type before your journey begins.
Is it related to The Witcher?
No. It has its own original world and isn’t connected to CD Projekt Red.
Five free chapters
One person’s dark fantasy, playable in your browser.
An honest comparison
One person. A lot of AI. No pretending otherwise.
Ash & Oath is a passion project from a single developer, and part of its purpose is to test what AI can do in game development. AI tools helped create its art, 3D models, audio and code, and it’s still in beta.
The Witcher 3 and all related names are trademarks of their respective owners. Ash & Oath is an independent project, with no connection to or endorsement from them. Details about The Witcher 3 were checked in October 2026 and may have changed.